Sunday, September 25, 2011

Making a Poem

1 man's poem by mark k



One Man’s Poem
By morning all is shot to hell
                        -Ashbery

Two hours of lousy sleep and an inauspicious beginning,
I apologize in advance for the coffee.
But even in deepest sleep,
the muscle memory of my meat heart,
my meat brain,
the flashlight fans out
an empty room.
And how do I even know the room exists?
If I fret over being ejected from it
by monster, landlord or thief maybe
I’m already out of it, or was never
in it to begin with, or don’t
even know what “it” is. Possession
and loss is a coin toss into
a gaping hole.
And angst isn’t fear, not really.
It’s fatigue that won’t rest on a treadmill of dread.

And one day I’ll be done
testing the formula
for the model that’s been rattling along
the superhighway for years,
decades, if truth be told.
And it must be told.
Unless I am to have no name.
But that’s tomorrow’s business, not mine.

Robert Mapplethorpe, Self Portrait


Last Wednesday I read a remarkable poem by Brendan MacOdrum of Oran’s Well. If You Read This is a long poem, part memoir part social commentary part cultural history. The past, Brendan writes, “is now nothing but retro” and contemporary consciousness is not much more than a “balloon of white noise.” He questions why for years music satisfied him and then “singing reached a frozen silent /shore where I couldn’t turn another/loss into another 3-chord bad angel.” He mentions Julian Jaynes, where I first learned about Thamyris, a poet mentioned in the Iliad who boasted that he could control the Muses. Enraged, they crippled him, took away his ability to play the harp, and caused him to lose his way as an artist. Brendan writes:

There are blues that no one sings
because there aren’t chords sour enough for them,
because there’s cold that cracks even a soul on ice,
because the singer lost his guitar and then his voice
and walks the blasted city streets of the
heart’s January like death in a dead tongue….

If You Read This begins: “Sleep did not come easy last night” and that night I had terrible dreams. I did not become lucid, take control of the dreams, nor wake up. I was too tired and only had a few hours before the cursed alarm bell. So I slept and suffered through this tired reminder of how I got my biggest scars. That monster has been chasing me around the block since I was a kid. He’s not scary. Far from it. I know every hair on his insipid body. He’s a cartoon I can draw with my eyes closed. In the morning I thought, this is how death will capture me - just weary of it all, like I’m done.

In the morning, all morning at work I was in a funk, could not get out. I used to fall into pits of depression that would sometimes last for weeks. I’d feel powerless to climb out of the pit on my own, would have to wait it out. A moment would come when the light would change and the world would take on a different appearance. The pit of depression, I learned, was my own self-centeredness. Yet chastising myself on that account only set a rat to scurrying in my brain. If I was lucky I’d see the humor in this and lo, a handhold out! I’ve learned to put up with a lot from myself over the years and the moods aren’t so dark or long lasting anymore. So this recent morning I’m talking about - last Thursday morning - was disappointing. I’m better than this! All morning long I played with the lines of the poem, One Man’s Poem. During my lunch break I wrote the words down.

“By morning all is shot to hell” is the last line of John Ashbery’s poem also entitled One Man's Poem. Ashbery is an artistic beacon for me. He is one of those, like Francesco Clemente and Pat Metheny, who shine a brilliant light in the world. They represent a type of integrity that I aspire to: a steadfast commitment to artistic ideals, not as a religion but for the sake of beauty itself. That’s a kind of faith that I can believe in, and it’s something that the world is ever in desperate need of. Just some music. Just some light. Just some beauty, for God’s sake. Readers of Ashbery will be surprised at that line; I could not avoid beginning with that surprise.

In the opening pages of The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind Julian Jaynes posits that consciousness is not at all the thing that people tend to think it is. Specifically, it comprises a “much smaller part of our mental life” than we think it does. I’m not sure consciousness is exactly what Jaynes says it is either, but the book asks fascinating questions and in this passage he equates our use of consciousness to shining a flashlight in a dark room searching for anything that does not have light shining on it. Since everything we can see has light shining on it we conclude that the flashlight - consciousness - encompasses everything. This happens when we think about consciousness, about what it is. But what is consciousness when we don’t think about it? I can’t climb out of my own pit on my own volition. I have to forget about the pit and then, suddenly, I’ll find that I’m out of it. The moment just prior to that is One Man’s Poem. It’s not beautiful, and I’m truly sorry for that. But I think there’s a small truth in it, and there will be better days and better poems. 

36 comments:

  1. "The pit of depression, I learned, was my own self-centeredness. Yet chastising myself on that account only set a rat to scurrying in my brain."

    "And angst isn’t fear, not really.
    It’s fatigue that won’t rest on a treadmill of dread."

    "But that’s tomorrow’s business, not mine."

    ...Wow... There is so much to think about here and each of the above could be a poem in and of themselves. That first line really, really is an eye opener! I don't get depressed, but I get crabby... but I think the same premise applies. A lot of work went into this post. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  2. really like you verse...the meat, the meat, the flashlight empty room...i find it haunting...brendans post was stellar and much to be gleened from...i am sure he will appreciate your thoughts...my thoughts grow dark at times...my own self centeredness...yes...

    ReplyDelete
  3. I need to take time and care over reading the entire poem, somewhen.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Margaret: Crabby? I have no idea what you're talking about. No, I'm kidding. I think, or at least Hope to Dear Jesus that when I get grumpy I'm better able to keep it to myself than I used to be. Even so, I tend to get very quiet, and that freaks people out.

    Thank you, Brian.

    Martin: I guess you mean Brendan's poem. Please don't let my tale of bad dreams dissuade you. It says at least as much about me as it does the poem, probably more. Besides, a poem should be like an ax to the frozen sea within us. Don't let the length bother you either. It's about as long as The Wasteland - that's not very long. Besides, Brendan happens to be what a lot of folks aspire to: a good writer. In terms of the language alone, he's a pleasure to read.

    ReplyDelete
  5. 'if i fret' and 'testing the formula.' for me, that's the meat of this, the angst line is the boutique line.

    i love ashbury's quote:)

    ReplyDelete
  6. "I have to forget about the pit and then, suddenly, I’ll find that I’m out of it." Sage words, I think, and amazing how that works (when it does, which is likely not every time). I love the Ashbery quote, and yes, I was surprised it was his. I don't seem to have that poem--must be in a more recent volume than the ones I now own. More to look forward to, then.

    As for your poem, whatever rough edges it may have, it captures something quite authentic. Indeed, the roughness may be part of what makes it work.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I wonder just how Thamyris thought he could control his Muses -- by understanding his dreams? Or were dreams sent to maim his artistic arrogance? There's such a watery link between oracles, dreams, and poetry - they share some sort of saltwater mortar -- So many of the poems I write and read figure prominently with dreams. (Thanks for the mention of mine, and for being brave enough to read through.) I like what you said in your comment about "a poem should be like an ax to the frozen sea within us"; and dreams so often hand us the weapon/tool, up from the unconscious mere like the Lady of the Lake. Our dreams communicate with each other, too -- I've heard of other occasions where someone's poem that figures a dream inspires another dream. Like there's a more general conversation going on by ghosts and oracles through the medium of our latter-day poems. The exhaustion and fear and oppression is real, I think -- the sense that poems are ending, the way that oracles died from a culture's lips -- but that it's important to pay attention to this dying, as whatever is to come is written on walls like these. My kid brother who died at 44 had a mantra: "Beauty Heals," and I too hold that the aesthetic of beauty is faith enough to help us die with a modicum of peace. The dream series or repeated motif is a special axe, we have a history with it, breaking through ceiling after floor after ceiling of ice, naming what we find there even though no name or depth's sufficient. We'll never get to the last room of the dream, or to the last draft of a poem, before we are, as you say, "done testing the formula:: At least we had a good time of it ... And yes, Metheny is the anti-Thamyris, a deep song welled from countless surrenders ... his humility is all ... Thanks again - Brendan

    ReplyDelete
  8. Ed: Glad you got some meat out of it.

    Susan: It's from the book entitled Wakefulness. Here is an excerpt:

    He came to see a tailor.
    More about it I do not know....

    ...for as far as we forgotten
    come together to make sense
    by midnight's shattered drum....

    The waves of freshman and sophomore grief
    slide by me somehow.
    We are old and dated
    and cannot of our lives make any sense....

    There is more than the spirit jabs,

    under the little hollow birds creep
    and are asked forgiveness. Some are afraid
    that they will fly away.
    By morning all is shot to hell.

    ReplyDelete
  9. There's a simplicity at the heart of most of your poems, Mark, that opens the door to thought. It's a true gift, or art, or however you want to perceive those expressions that come from some deep place we are born with, and that living either frees or dilutes.It's been my pleasure and privilege to read brendan's work for a few months now, and he also has that quality. These are the basic issues of living, or perception, you both explore,and following your flashlights as they play in the dark brings things out of the shadow we otherwise might never see.
    This is an excellent look at that mind cage in which we rattle the bars til we suddenly see the door is not locked. I rely on my dreams for the voice in them, even when it cries instead of sings. Thanks for the turn on to Ashbery and Jaynes--on my booklist--and for this collection of thoughts and words you've made into a poem.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Brendan: I love your question about dreams. A dream life can go both ways, and in the cycles of a person's life one can experience dreams as a pathway to creativity or as a choking off of the spirit. The Iliad barely mentions Thamyris. My translation says he boasted that he could "surpass" the Muses, indicating that he was so full of his own power that he felt he could fly without dreams. Well, he couldn't.

    I love calling Metheny the anti-Thamyris! You've obviously been touched by his music.

    The statement about the ax comes from Kafka. He said a book should be an ax to the frozen sea within us.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Joy: I've come to appreciate your comments, not just to my poems, but the poems of others as well. I made this post because a few readers have indicated to me in the past that they might like to see how a poem is made. The process varies, of course, and sometimes it wouldn't make for an interesting story. Other times, like this one, even I am surprised by how it's done. Thanks for what you say about simplicity and thought. I don't believe that complex thoughts have to be stated in convoluted ways. I've worked very hard to achieve clarity of expression.

    I think you'll get a HUGE kick out of Jaynes! There's a ton of Ashbery material online, at Ubuweb, PennSound, and the Ashbery Resource Center (link on my sidebar). Thank you, Joy.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Without dreams we truly are nothing but an empty room. It's interesting to see where they take us and if they are relevant or not to anything in particular. Darkened thoughts arise at times in us all, with worries abound, enjoyed the piece it works for both dreamscape and reality or both.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I lost my previous comment somehow and now feel a bit depressed about the whole thing. Wait... I'm being self-centered b/c I don't want to type all that again.

    Seriously, I agree, but sometimes depression can be a medical problem such as hormones, chemical imbalances, etc.

    I esp. liked:

    Possession
    and loss is a coin toss into
    a gaping hole.
    And angst isn’t fear, not really.
    It’s fatigue that won’t rest on a treadmill of dread.

    ReplyDelete
  14. mark - first - i could listen to you for hours...your reading added to the depth of this poem...it sent shivers down my spine - so deep and heartfelt...loved it - and thanks for also sharing some of the background...poetry coming from real life, born in hours of weakness is most of the time the strongest poetry...this is strong write for sure

    ReplyDelete
  15. Poets write because they feel so much more than many others... felt it in your words today

    ReplyDelete
  16. Pat: I can't think of a poem/post more unlike the joyful, sometimes irreverent rhythmical work you do; I appreciate you looking into this dark room.

    Laurie: You make an important point that should always be borne in mind when writing about depression and the overcoming of it. Some people need medical help; that's a fact.

    Claudia: Mutual Admiration Society going on here!

    Patricia: Jackson Pollock once said he felt like he was born without skin. I wish I didn't know what he meant.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I know that pit far better than I want to. Do you think that's part of the creative process, a place we have to dig through to get at what we need to say?

    I enjoyed this look into the shadows and learned from it.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Mark...honestly, my heart cries tears of appreciation and kinship for this amazing presentation. The reading was wonderful, the dialogue fantastic...and...there`s so much I could say, but most of all, I feel such a sincere truth behind it all. Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  19. The meat, meat part caught my attention too. I thought our heart is muscle, our brain is some kind of matter but, they meat and meat, we are meat. Thank you for your poem today, it is one I can absorb and get better grasp of reading poems and hopefully of writing them.

    ReplyDelete
  20. So much to think about.... but first, your poem is awesome and don't apologize to me because my little talent couldn't reach that kind of intense writing with a ten foot pole... I mean, come on, "meat heart"??? That's awesome! Secondly, I've had those dreams all my life too, just haven't been able to describe it as completely touching as drawing a cartoon in my sleep. Frankenstein chases me. Yes it's stupid, but it scared me to death when I was a kid. Now it doesn't scare me anymore because after all of these years I have come to believe that he cannot hurt me, so I spend the length of those dreams running around warning other people that he is coming, more concerned for them than myself because remember? I'm invincible. And Mark, that's the God's honest truth. I also suffer from clinical depression. It's not a stigma, and I'm not embarrassed of it. But other people do misunderstand it. It's not sadness. Sadness is only one symptom of it. Medication helps me to sleep and to be healthy. And you know I have a lot of really good dreams too Mark. I like to focus on those ones. Thirdly, (is that a word?) I am adding Ashbery to my reading list. I've never read him before, but if you like him, then I have a feeling I will to. And finally fourthly, (I'm pretty sure that is definitely not a word) you have a new follower... really good poem for someone who was probably really exhausted... been there....

    ReplyDelete
  21. I admire Brendan's posts, he is a terrific writer.

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts and post.. I appreciate the ramblings of your mind, if I may call it that.

    As I am new in writing, I find a deep well within me that needs to come out.. so finding expression for these thoughts through poetry and otherwise have been very fulfilling. I can understand one's turmoil in the writing process but for me, I am just starting my journey. This is just one of my blog; my other is a nature themed one and it has been rewarding as well.

    As to your post, these lines struck a chord in me:
    Possession
    and loss is a coin toss into
    a gaping hole.
    And angst isn’t fear, not really.
    It’s fatigue that won’t rest on a treadmill of dread.

    ReplyDelete
  22. "Possession and loss is a coin toss into a gaping hole" and "a treadmill of dread" are phrases from your poem that resonate deeply with me. I have spent a while reading all you have written here and enjoyed hearing your ideas. I have discovered the joys of a muse companion in in the past couple of years. Truly an amazing phenomenon. I cannot summon the muse but have come to recognize receptive states that tempt her/him, such as half awake, not dreams really, but an intermediary place, or in the shower, or driving the back country roads. Solitude is critical for me.

    Thank you for this philosophical interlude.

    ReplyDelete
  23. All is interesting but I most love the line re possession and loss.

    ReplyDelete
  24. I appreciated how passionately you dove into your own influences and inspirations. The essay is unguarded in its admiration for others. Almost wholly unqualified. That's admirable and emboldens all senses of endorsement.

    Much less philosophical: I couldn't get the audio via Shuffle to play in Firefox 6 or IE. Reloaded in both venues to no effect. Is it working for you, Mark?

    ReplyDelete
  25. Sadly, I couldn't access the audio either, but your poem is powerful and resonates for me...as someone who as suffered depression and has lived with those dark thoughts daily. And if you can't sleep (or dream) getting out of that hole is nigh impossible ...great write, Mark.

    ReplyDelete
  26. I've worked with people who suffer from depression and sometimes have dark moments myself, so can relate to the fatigue, especially.

    I've stopped apologising for the coffee. I need it to live;)

    ReplyDelete
  27. Terrific poem! I especially love the last line. It seems you have come to a kind of acceptance. Much to think about.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Thank you everyone for reading and visiting.

    Nara: Certainly I believe solitary meditation is essential for writing but depression is absolutely NOT essential.

    John R: You don't need a 10 foot pole, your pen works just fine. The 'cleave' poem you posted is fantastic. Can't tell you how much I enjoy your comments.

    Ann: Being visited by a muse can be an amazing phenomenon, as you say, far more profound than the facile metaphor people often use. Remember the example of Thamyris, respect your muse, but even so know that they come and go as they please.

    John W: Thanks for alerting me to that problem, which I've had before. Hopefully Soundcloud will be a better host.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Do like the physical, tangible, meaty opening, Mark... great place from which to reflect.

    the flashlight fans out
    an empty room.

    ..this a perfect vignette. Pause for thought.. thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  30. The meat, the meat...that particular bit resonated cerebral for me, pounding home the substance - frail, simple - of man. Very physical, as Becky noted, and open to a lot of reflection. A dark engagement, supplemented with heartfelt and engaging dialogue. Superb, and in particular, this line sang to me: "Possession and loss is a coin toss into a gaping hole" Marvelous.

    Of curious note, though, I see some of your commenters noting that the audio isn't working with firefox...but I am also utilizing firefox, yet it works fine. Perhaps you've corrected it by now, but I just wanted to note it may not be a firefox issue.

    ReplyDelete
  31. You know, Mark, I am never disappointed when I visit your blogs, The Bricoleur, in particular. It takes me back a couple of years when I used to read Penn poets (profs & students blogs), ergo, my first taste of Ashbery. You throw in your poem; Mapplethorpe's fab self port; Methany (haven't popped in the trio for a while...now will at work tomorrow) and the wonderful sidebar commentary about your psyche...dang, its a visit to the lecture hall while enjoying a fab fall day via macbook.

    What I am trying to say is, "Thank you"; it is just such a brilliant package you offer your readers that are wise enough to visit. I had made a mental note about Jaynes last week, but had forgotten. This also is a nice add on to a book I'm now starting, The Master and his Emissary, a different look at the brain, not so much the conscious, but alas how it shapes us based on its divisive nature, literally.

    Finally, I love your honesty. The "self-centeredness" observation is one that I must add to my self catalogue. I've other thoughts on the depths of hell (why I roam from time to time) but "s-c" I had not added to my equation, though, I so understand.

    Sorry about this novella....but please note your work is very much valued and appreciated ~ angela

    ReplyDelete
  32. A lot to absorb here, reserving deeper comments until I can do them justice. It was wonderful to hear you do the reading. I can say that I believe consciousness is not just leaving the pit but allowing yourself the ability to experience even our 'pits' without losing the hearts joy. The experience of all emotions and environments without losing joy. The experience of all things with centered, joyful heart is my ultimate goal of my practice. Lovely piece this week my friend ~ Rose

    ReplyDelete
  33. Rose: That's a laudable goal. And you bring an excellent dimension to the discussion - the kind of growing and deepening of self-awareness over time that we might call spirituality.

    Angela: It doesn't surprised you're a Metheny fan, there's so much music in your poetry. If that's the Trio 99-00 album it's got one of my all time favorite tracks on it: Just Like the Day.

    Thanks to everyone for your warm responses.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Hey Mark, I'm continuing on the Lascaux theme today -- I'd love it if you'd have a look and put in your two cents. - Brendan http://blueoran.wordpress.com/2011/09/29/cave-painter/

    ReplyDelete
  35. I've almost drowned at the deep dark end of the pool of sleeplessness at one long period in my life. Seen the haloed light of day that feels the same fuzzy, gummy consistency as relentlessly hellish night. I felt this poem in that way, a deja vu of a time I would love to forget. I'm always enlightened when I visit here, Mark

    ReplyDelete
  36. Brendan MacOdrum @ Oran’s Well is a literary force, depth and heart to behold. I am grateful to call him friend.

    ReplyDelete